CDF Task Force Hardware Warnings


IBM Deskstar 75/120GXP IDE Hard Drives

Disks which belong to the IBM Deskstar families 75GXP and 120GXP have some issues:

75GXP

Over 50% of the IBM Deskstar 75GXP IDE disks in the trailers have needed to be replaced due to mechanical failure.

120GXP

This family of disks is fairly new, and those that are in the trailers are still functioning; however, IBM has released a spec sheet with a handy chart on page 2. Under "Reliability", there is an entry which reads:
Recommended power-on hours (monthly) 333
Just more than 11 hours per day. Compare this to an article from storagereview.com dated 03/06/2002 and titled "More on 120GXPs and servers" where IBM tech support allegedly states "the drive is intended to be on for no more than about 8 hours a day."


3Ware Escalade IDE RAID controllers and Western Digital Hard Drives

Disclaimer: The following was discovered during testing. Support of 3Ware IDE RAID controllers is NOT implied.

While wrestling with continued RAID5 array degradation, 3Ware tech support informed us that Western Digital hard drives don't play well with the 3Ware Escalade IDE RAID controller. A disk will timeout and the controller will drop the disk from the array, putting the array into a degraded state. This is problematic if two drives happen to timeout. (see RAID0, RAID5 and Array Degradation )


updated 11Apr2002 by